I once knew a creative team where the CW was a little more adored and befriended by agency leadership than the AD. Not sure why. Just the way it was. (It wasn’t me, by the way.)
At one point, the AD was frustrated enough with the situation to talk to our ECD about it. Hoping to convey her neglected value, she even said, “That [redacted] campaign we just did? [It had just appeared in Archive.] That was all my idea! I did the whole thing – he just changed one word in the tag!”
The reason I know she said that was because within a week, almost everyone in the creative department knew she had said it. That she would claim sole authorship on some work, however accurate, seemed, as one coworker put it, “so unprofessional.”
A couple morals to this story:
1. I have never heard a story about a creative who complained about anything to an ECD to their benefit. Complaining just doesn’t get you anywhere. Not even when it’s about your clients.
2. You can create an entire campaign on your own. But if you’re part of a team, you did the work as a team. A little humility is a good thing. (And if your partner’s not doing his or her share, it will show. You don’t have to put up any red flags. Your CDs are probably more aware than you know.)
6 thoughts on “A Cautionary Tale”
Sounds like a growth opportunity. Not creative talent, but people skills. As you advance in your career, you have to learn to play the system, bit your tongue and just hit creative home runs at every bat.
It's pretty obvious when only one person in the team is pulling their weight. And it becomes obvious who's pulling that weight once you guys get split up and work with different people.
This goes for presenting too. When you're presenting an idea to a CD or a client or whomever, it shouldn't be obvious that one person came up with the idea. It's “We had this idea,” not “I had this idea.”
The one exception to this is if you really are in disagreement and at an impasse. Have a meeting with your CD, let him/her know that you guys are in different places and ask him/her to weigh in.
You're site is a great resource. Not only for students, but for us “seasoned” ad people as well. The tongue-in-cheek observations are spot-on and I laugh out loud while remembering my earlier agency days! I'm recommending your site and advice to my graduating adv. students as required reading before they leave the security of academia.
Thanks for the kind words. Really glad you enjoy the blog.
Everyone should make the effort to achieve success – as a team.